Sports 17 sources · over 4 days Latest coverage 14 Oct 2026, 7:02 pm UTC

Carrick under pressure as Martinez criticism deepens Manchester United's troubles

A Champions League defeat has intensified pressure on Michael Carrick, while Lisandro Martinez's criticism of Manchester United's recruitment has prompted a possible disciplinary response.

By Hushread Stories, written with AI from 17 outlets · First published 14 Oct 2026 · Chapter 2 of 2

Earlier: Carrick Under Pressure as Atletico Defeat Sparks Criticism of United Board

In brief

  1. Manchester United drew with Tottenham despite leading against ten men, leaving them with six points from six league matches.
  2. United then lost two nil at Atletico Madrid in the Champions League, with Yoro sent off.
  3. Lisandro Martinez criticised the hierarchy after the Madrid defeat, accusing the club of failing to invest sufficiently.
  4. Carrick backed United to recover before the Madrid match but subsequently declined to comment on Martinez's remarks.
  5. United bosses are assessing Martinez's comments before deciding whether to take disciplinary action against the defender.
Carrick under pressure as Martinez criticism deepens Manchester United's troubles
Source: Express & Star

Timeline · 7 moments

7 moments Open the full timeline →

United assess Martinez comments before deciding disciplinary action

ESPN FC ↗

Carrick declines to comment on Martinez's public remarks

L'Équipe ↗

Martinez doubles down on criticism of United hierarchy

Express & Star ↗

Martinez attacks hierarchy over Champions League squad quality

ESPN FC ↗

United lose at Atletico as Yoro sees red

Express & Star ↗

Mainoo and Shaw miss trip as Carrick promises fight

Latest news, sport and opinion from the Guardian ↗

Tottenham draw brings boos and further pressure on Carrick

The42 ↗

How it started

Manchester United's latest difficulties began with another home result that left Michael Carrick facing boos. On October 10, United drew 1-1 with Tottenham despite holding both a goal advantage and a numerical advantage after 90 minutes, according to ESPN FC.

Dominic Solanke equalised in added time. It was United's second successive home league match without beating opponents reduced to ten men, The42 reported. Carrick said the boos hurt.

The result left United with six points from six league matches, their worst league start in nearly 40 years, according to Times of India. The immediate problem was not simply dropping points, but failing again to make an advantage count.

How it unfolded

On October 12, Carrick insisted United would turn things around ahead of their Champions League match at Atletico Madrid, ESPN FC reported. His preparations were complicated by the absence of Kobbie Mainoo and Luke Shaw, who had picked up knocks against Tottenham and did not travel to Madrid, according to the Guardian.

The concerns extended beyond results. That day, Jamie Carragher highlighted United's lack of intensity when pressing against Tottenham and said continued shortcomings would bring further questions about Carrick, Sky Sports reported.

On October 13, United lost 2-0 at Atletico Madrid. Yoro was sent off in the second half, according to Express & Star, adding another setback to Carrick's difficult start.

After the defeat, Lisandro Martinez shifted attention towards the club's hierarchy. He accused United's bosses of failing to prepare a "Champions League quality squad" and said players "expect more from the top", ESPN FC reported. The BBC reported that his criticism centred on the failure to strengthen after qualifying for the competition.

By October 14, the dispute had become a story in its own right. Martinez doubled down on his criticism of director of football Jason Wilcox and the board, according to Express & Star. Carrick declined to comment on the remarks, L'Équipe reported.

Where it stands

Carrick faces pressure over performances, while Martinez's intervention has brought recruitment and the hierarchy into the same argument. The criticism does not erase the team's failings against Tottenham or the defeat in Madrid, but it broadens the dispute beyond the manager.

The disciplinary position remains unsettled in the supplied reporting. GB News reported that United were set to fine Martinez. However, ESPN FC, citing sources, reported that club bosses were still assessing his comments before deciding whether to take disciplinary action. A punishment should therefore not be treated as confirmed.

Wayne Rooney called Martinez's public remarks disrespectful, according to Times of India. The coverage establishes mounting pressure on Carrick, but does not confirm a decision about his future.

What to watch

The immediate pending decision is whether United punish Martinez over his comments. ESPN FC reported that the club's assessment was still under way, making the outcome of that review the clearest next development.

On the pitch, the specific issue is whether Carrick's players can produce the improvement he promised before Madrid. Sky Sports identified their pressing intensity as a concern, while the Tottenham draw exposed another failure to finish off opponents reduced to ten men.

Spotted an error? Email [email protected] and we'll fix it.

More in Sports

All →