Lindsay Clancy to be retried in March 2027 after first murder trial ends in mistrial
A Massachusetts judge has set a new trial date for Lindsay Clancy, accused of killing her three children, after a deadlocked jury forced a mistrial in September.
By Hushread Stories, from 30 outlets · First published 16 Nov 2026
In brief
- Lindsay Clancy returned to a Plymouth County courtroom on November 16 for a hearing on how her case will proceed.
- Judge William Sullivan set her second trial to begin on March 29, 2027, after the first trial ended without a verdict.
- The first trial ended in a mistrial in early September after a 12-person jury could not reach a verdict.
- Clancy faces first-degree murder charges in the deaths of her children Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and Callan, 8 months.
- Prosecutors refused to lower the charges and denied a request to delay the retrial until summer, while the defence argues insanity.
Timeline · 8 moments
Clancy asks top court to throw out case before retrial
ABC News ↗Consultant says impartial jury for Clancy retrial may be harder
Top Stories ↗Judge sets March 29, 2027 retrial date for Clancy
CBS Top Stories ↗Judge sets March 29 retrial date after prosecutors refuse to lower charges
South China Morning Post ↗Judge sets second trial for March 29, 2027
Yahoo! UK News ↗Clancy returns to Plymouth County court for hearing
ABCNews.com ↗Clancy due in court for pivotal retrial hearing
CNN Top Stories ↗First trial ends in mistrial after jury deadlock
BBC News ↗Update 19 Nov 2026, 6:53 am UTC
Clancy's lawyers have now filed an appeal with Massachusetts' highest court asking it to throw out the triple murder case before the March 2027 retrial, according to ABC News. A jury consultant also warned, in coverage from Top Stories, that finding an impartial jury for the second trial may be even harder than the first, with the so-called stealth juror a possible factor. The retrial date and the decision to retry are unchanged, so the headline still stands.
Update 18 Nov 2026, 0:20 am UTC
The retrial date of March 29, 2027 is now confirmed by CBS Top Stories, which reported Judge William Sullivan set it after the first trial ended with a hung jury. Forbes notes the retrial begins just under seven months after that mistrial. The published headline already reflects the March retrial, so the core facts still hold and only the key points need tightening.
Update 17 Nov 2026, 6:21 am UTC
The retrial date is now confirmed in coverage from CNA and The New York Times: Judge William Sullivan set jury proceedings to begin on March 29, 2027, after the first trial ended in a mistrial in early September. Prosecutors declined to lower the murder charges, and their request to delay the retrial until summer was denied. The defence continues to argue insanity, with lawyers claiming postpartum psychosis while prosecutors say the killings were planned.
Update 16 Nov 2026, 11:00 pm UTC
Coverage from November 16 confirms the retrial decision and sets the second trial for March 29, 2027, as Court TV and CNN reported. Prosecutors declined to lower the first-degree murder charges, and Judge William Sullivan denied their request to delay the retrial until summer, according to Court TV. The published piece already holds the core facts, so the headline and dek still stand, with only the key points refreshed.
How it started
Lindsay Clancy is a Massachusetts mother accused of killing her three children in 2023. CNN described the case that way when it reported on her return to court, noting that she argues she should not be held criminally responsible.
She is charged with first-degree murder in the deaths of 5-year-old Cora, 3-year-old Dawson and 8-month-old Callan, according to a report on the hearing. Yahoo UK described her as a former labour and delivery nurse, aged 36.
How it unfolded
The first trial ran for weeks over the summer. The BBC reported that it fell apart in early September, when a 12-person jury could not reach a verdict. The result was a mistrial rather than an acquittal or a conviction, which left the charges standing.
In the weeks that followed, attention turned to what prosecutors would do next. On November 15, CNN previewed a pivotal Monday appearance that should reveal if and when Clancy would again stand trial. CBS reported that prosecutors were expected to announce how they planned to proceed, and that the hearing would also address what charges she would face.
On Monday, November 16, Clancy returned to the Plymouth County Superior Court. ABC News reported that Judge William Sullivan had scheduled the hearing to formally set a trial date.
By the end of the hearing there was an answer. The New York Post reported that Clancy is slated to face trial again in March, and quoted the line 'The die has been cast' in its headline. Infobae, CNN Brasil and Yahoo UK all gave the date as March 29, 2027, with CNN Brasil noting it falls less than a year after the first trial's collapse.
Where it stands
Clancy will be tried a second time on the murder charges, with jury proceedings set to begin on March 29, 2027. Nothing from the first trial has been resolved, since the jury never delivered a verdict.
The coverage reviewed here confirms the date and the decision to retry, but does not detail any rulings on what exactly the charges will be beyond the murder counts already reported.
What to watch
The main open question is how the second trial will differ from the first, given that a jury could not agree the first time. The defence position that Clancy should not be held criminally responsible is already on the record, and any pretrial filings between now and late March may show how both sides adjust their approach.


