Manchester United bench Fernandes after Como defeat exposes dispute with Carrick
Bruno Fernandes has lost his starting place after publicly questioning Michael Carrick's tactics, turning Manchester United's heavy European defeat into a test of the manager's authority.
By Hushread Stories, from 23 outlets · First published 26 Oct 2026 · Chapter 5 of 5
Earlier: Como beat Manchester United 4-1 as Carrick faces tactical criticism
In brief
- Manchester United lost 4 to 1 away at Como in the Champions League on October 21.
- Nico Paz scored twice and supplied an assist as Como recorded their second Champions League victory.
- Captain Bruno Fernandes publicly questioned United's tactics, prompting an apparent exchange of criticism with Michael Carrick.
- Carrick accepted responsibility for United's slump but expressed confidence that he could turn their form around.
- Fernandes was benched against Bournemouth on October 25, with his starting place and captaincy now under scrutiny.
Timeline · 8 moments
Carrick calls Fernandes benching a football decision
Home | GB News ↗Fernandes dropped to bench for Bournemouth fixture
BBC Sport ↗Carrick rejects claims Manchester United are unmanageable
BBC - Home ↗Carrick accepts blame and backs himself to recover
Al Jazeera ↗Sources say Carrick will remain for Bournemouth match
ESPN FC ↗Carrick and Fernandes publicly exchange criticism after defeat
ESPN FC ↗Como dominate United in heavy Champions League defeat
CNN Brasil ↗Fabregas says Como can beat Manchester United
Adnkronos - ultimoratop ↗How it started
Como approached Manchester United's visit with respect, but not fear. Before the October 21 Champions League match, coach Cesc Fabregas said his side could win if they did things properly, according to Adnkronos.
The result justified that confidence. Como dominated United and won 4-1 at the Giuseppe Sinigaglia stadium in the third round of the league phase, CNN Brasil reported. For United, the defeat became more than another damaging scoreline: it brought disagreement between their manager and captain into public view.
How it unfolded
On October 21, Nicolás Paz struck after barely two minutes, following a pass from Lucas Da Cunha, according to La Nacion. Nico Paz finished with two goals and an assist for Douvikas, while Ramon also scored in Como's second Champions League victory, La Repubblica reported.
After the match, captain Bruno Fernandes publicly criticised United's tactics. ESPN FC reported that Fernandes and manager Michael Carrick appeared to trade criticism as the defeat threw Carrick's future into doubt.
The dispute also drew criticism of Fernandes. Jamie Carragher called his comments an "absolute disgrace", according to ESPN. That reaction shifted part of the debate from United's performance to whether their captain should have challenged the coaching publicly.
On October 22, Carrick said he had not given his own position any thought despite the "unacceptable" defeat, Al Jazeera reported. Separately, sources told ESPN FC that he was set to remain in charge for Bournemouth's visit on Sunday.
By October 23, Carrick had accepted blame for the slump and said he remained confident of a turnaround, according to Al Jazeera. He nevertheless refused to rule out dropping Fernandes against Bournemouth, ESPN FC reported.
On October 25, Fernandes was left on the bench for that match, BBC Sport reported. Carrick described the selection as a "pure football" decision, according to GB News, rather than publicly presenting it as punishment.
Where it stands
Carrick remained in charge for the Bournemouth fixture, but the wider pressure had not disappeared. Ahead of the match, the BBC reported that United had gone seven games without a win. Carrick also rejected the suggestion that the club was unmanageable.
Fernandes's omission is confirmed; a change of captain is not. On October 23, Carrick declined to confirm whether Fernandes would remain captain, according to The42. The supplied coverage does not give the Bournemouth result or establish whether the benching will extend beyond that match.
What to watch
The immediate questions are whether Fernandes returns to the starting side and whether Carrick makes a separate decision on the captaincy. His explanation of the Bournemouth selection leaves those issues open.
Carrick's position also remains unresolved. Reports about possible replacements should be treated cautiously: La Repubblica reported that United were exploring Antonio Conte's availability, while Cumhuriyet reported that Conte had been ruled out and Julian Nagelsmann was the strongest candidate. Those accounts conflict, and neither establishes an appointment.


