Warner Says 2018 Sandpaper Inquiry 'Stinks of a Cover-Up' as Australian Cricket Row Deepens
Australia's captain says he knew nothing about the 2018 ball-tampering plot, but David Warner and Chadd Sayers are contradicting him, and Cricket Australia now says players will probably never agree.
By Hushread Stories, from 18 outlets · First published 15 Nov 2026 · Chapter 1 of 5
In brief
- Captain Pat Cummins has denied any involvement in the 2018 ball-tampering scandal after claims by former teammate Usman Khawaja.
- David Warner says Josh Hazlewood, Mitchell Starc and Nathan Lyon were never interviewed in Cricket Australia's 2018 investigation.
- Warner has not retreated from calling the inquiry shoddy and a cover-up, and has asked why those players were left out.
- Former bowler Chadd Sayers again rejected Cummins' recollection, saying he believes everyone in the 2018 side knew about the sandpaper.
- Cricket Australia has admitted it is very unlikely the players on that tour will ever agree on what happened.
Timeline · 9 moments
Warner refuses to retreat from cover-up claim, questions omitted players
Gulf News ↗Cricket Australia says player agreement very unlikely
Latest news, sport and opinion from the Guardian ↗Sayers says he took sandpaper from the field
BBC - Home ↗Sayers says everyone knew about sandpaper
ABC Australia ↗Wasim Akram questions Cummins' denial
dawn.com ↗Warner accuses Cricket Australia of cover-up
BBC - Home ↗Warner says 2018 investigation stinks of cover-up
Guardian Sport ↗Cummins holds 68-minute news conference; papers react
BBC Sport ↗Cummins denies involvement after Khawaja's claims
Al Jazeera ↗Update 15 Nov 2026, 8:45 pm UTC
Two new reports from 15 November add detail but no resolution. Sky Sports reported that former bowler Chadd Sayers again rejected Pat Cummins' account, restating his belief that everyone in the 2018 side knew about the sandpaper plot. Gulf News reported that David Warner has not retreated from his claim that the investigation was a cover-up and has asked why players such as Josh Hazlewood, Mitchell Starc and Nathan Lyon were never interviewed. The core dispute is unchanged, so the published headline still holds.
How it started
The 2018 Sandpapergate scandal began on Australia's tour of South Africa, where the team was caught tampering with the ball. Warner, then vice-captain, captain Steve Smith and opener Cameron Bancroft all served lengthy bans, as the BBC noted.
The row came back to life with the publication of Usman Khawaja's book. Khawaja, a former teammate, made claims that linked Pat Cummins to the affair, according to Al Jazeera.
Cummins, now Australia's captain, rejected those claims outright.
How it unfolded
On 13 November, Cummins denied any involvement in the ball-tampering. Al Jazeera reported that he rejected Khawaja's claims, and BBC Sport described an extraordinary 68-minute news conference, with Australian newspapers saying the gloves were off.
The next day, Warner escalated things. He said the 2018 investigation "stinks of a cover-up" and named three bowlers, Hazlewood, Lyon and Starc, who he said were never interviewed. The Guardian reported that he called it a "shoddy investigation" run by Cricket Australia, and ESPNcricinfo carried the same claim.
Also on 14 November, Dawn reported that Pakistan fast-bowling great Wasim Akram questioned Cummins' denial. Akram argued that any experienced bowler would spot the use of sandpaper.
On 15 November, Sayers entered the argument. He played his only Test after the scandal and was part of the 2018 South Africa tour squad. ABC Australia reported that he is comfortable saying he believed everyone in the team knew about the ball-tampering.
The BBC added that Sayers said he took sandpaper from the field and rejects Cummins' recount. It also noted that he had earlier backed Khawaja's recollections, saying "everything" in the book was "accurate".
Where it stands
The dispute is unresolved and the sides are further apart. Cummins has said he wants to draw a line under the matter, while Warner and Sayers are publicly challenging his account.
The Guardian reported that Cricket Australia has admitted there is little hope of reaching agreement on what happened, as divisions deepen between the players on the 2018 tour. The governing body has not shown any sign that it will reopen the original inquiry.
What to watch
The main open question is whether Cricket Australia responds to the cover-up allegation beyond saying agreement is unlikely. Hazlewood, Lyon and Starc, the three bowlers Warner named, have not been quoted in the coverage so far, and anything they say would matter.
It is also unclear whether other members of the 2018 squad will speak, as Sayers has, and how that affects Cummins' position as captain.


