Disclosure: Hushread is my app. I’ve tried to be fair, and I say where the others are the better choice.

In the SmartNews vs Apple News choice, Apple News is the better pick for most iPhone owners in the US, UK, Canada or Australia: it’s already installed, editors choose the top stories, and its App Store privacy label lists no data used to track you, while SmartNews’s lists nine kinds. SmartNews wins if you also use Android, live in Japan, want a political-balance slider, or want to pay a few dollars to strip most ads. Both are free and both show ads. SmartNews also had two security incidents in late October 2026, and some of its US features were still paused on November 4.

SmartNews vs Apple News at a glance

US App Store listings and prices, checked on 14 November 2026:

SmartNewsApple News
PriceFree, with adsFree, with ads
Paid option“Ads-free SmartNews”, $3.99 or $4.99 in-app (period not stated)News+ at $12.99 a month, not sold as ad-free
Who picks the storiesEditors and an algorithmEditors, personalized on your device
Data Used to Track You (privacy label)Nine categoriesNone listed
DevicesiPhone, iPad, Apple Vision, AndroidiPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Vision
CountriesUS and Japan editionsAustralia, Canada, UK, US
Local newsLocation-based updates, USLocal feed, US only
App Store rating4.6 from 929K ratings4.6 from 1.7M ratings

Who decides what you see

SmartNews: editors plus an algorithm

SmartNews describes its feed as a “thoughtful blend of editor and algorithmic curation” from “Over 4,500 Trusted Publishers” (SmartNews). The feature Apple has no answer to is the slider: SmartNews says you can “See coverage from reputable sources across both sides of the political spectrum with our easy slider feature.”

Apple News: editors first, then you

Apple’s listing promises “Top stories curated by editors, personalized for you,” with local news sources from all 50 US states, London and the seven largest Canadian cities (App Store). The personalization stays on the phone: “Recommendations in Apple News are made based on the information stored on your device,” and your reading activity “is not associated with your Apple Account” (Apple News & Privacy).

So the split isn’t human versus machine. Both use editors.

Privacy and tracking

This is the clearest gap between the two.

SmartNews’s label has a “Data Used to Track You” box, meaning data that “may be used to track you across apps and websites owned by other companies.” It lists Location, Contact Info, User Content, Search History, Browsing History, Identifiers, Usage Data, Diagnostics and Other Data (App Store). The Data Linked to You section names precise location among the data used for third-party advertising.

SmartNews App Store privacy label showing a Data Used to Track You box listing nine categories, including location, contact info, search history and browsing history The App Privacy section of SmartNews’s US App Store listing, 14 November 2026. Source: apps.apple.com

Apple News’s label has no “Data Used to Track You” section at all. It isn’t empty, though: purchase history, coarse location, a user ID, a device ID and usage data are linked to you for third-party advertising. Apple runs those ads itself, and if you turn off the Personalized Ads setting, Apple says it stops using your account details and the topics and publications you follow “for ad targeting.” If tracking across other apps is what you want to avoid, Apple News is the safer of the two.

Ads and paying to remove them

Both free apps carry ads. Apple says Apple News “is ad supported,” and SmartNews’s App Store age rating lists “Contains: advertising.”

SmartNews sells a real way out, with caveats. Its Ads-Free plan lets you read “without advertisements, subject to certain exceptions”: publishers can still add their own ads and promotional links, and sponsored videos or live streams may carry branded messages. To buy it you must be 18 or older (or have a guardian’s consent), be on the US edition, and have your Apple or Google ID set to the US (SmartNews terms). The terms leave the price to the app; the US App Store lists two “Ads-free SmartNews” purchases, at $3.99 and $4.99, without saying what period each covers.

Apple News+ is a different product. It costs $12.99 a month after a one-month free trial and adds more than 500 magazines, newspapers and digital publishers, audio stories and puzzles (Apple). It’s also part of Apple One Premier at $39.95 a month. Apple’s pages don’t say News+ removes ads. The Kirkville blog, explaining in February 2026 why its author won’t pay for News+, put it this way: “while you get more publications, you still get ads” (Kirkville).

So: pay SmartNews to see fewer ads, pay Apple to read more paywalled publications. If News+ is the thing you’re weighing, I went through it in Is Apple News+ worth it.

SmartNews’s October 2026 security incidents

On October 22, 2026, SmartNews suspended some services after a third party exploited a vulnerability in its servers, and the next day said core services were back and it had found no evidence of a personal data leak (SmartNews). On October 31 it reported another unauthorized access to its systems and paused some features again (SmartNews).

By its November 4 update, push notifications were back, personalization was being restored gradually, reading and refreshing articles worked as usual, and missions and rewards, including earning and redeeming points, were still suspended (SmartNews). That matters if the reading-rewards program SmartNews launched in March 2026 was part of the appeal (SmartNews).

SmartNews newsroom notice dated November 4, 2026, titled Update: Status of Some Features in the U.S. Edition, saying a third party gained unauthorized access on October 31 and some features were suspended SmartNews’s update on the US edition after the October 31 access, published 4 November 2026. Source: about.smartnews.com

On November 6 the company said the data leaked in the October 31 access covered email addresses for 1,582 publisher contacts and 207 advertising partners, plus 1,033 internal user IDs that it says “cannot identify an individual on their own.” It said no passwords or credit card information were included, and warned users to be wary of messages claiming to be from SmartNews (SmartNews). For a reader, the practical damage is small. It’s still worth knowing, given how much the privacy label says the app collects.

Countries, devices and local news

Apple News is available in four countries: Australia, Canada, the UK and the US, and News+ and audio stories are limited to the same four (Apple feature availability). Its local news feed is US-only; elsewhere you can follow a location instead (Apple support). It runs only on Apple hardware, including the Mac.

SmartNews runs on iPhone, iPad and Apple Vision (iOS 17 or later) and on Android. Its company site describes two editions, Japan and the US (SmartNews), and the US App Store listing reads “Read in English or Spanish.” Local news, weather and crime alerts are a big part of its pitch in the US. If you switch between an iPhone and an Android phone, or your household does, SmartNews is the only one of the two that follows you.

Neither company publishes a list of local outlets per town, so check your own town in both.

What neither app does

Neither lets you add a source of your own. Both choose from their own catalogs, and both put that catalog in an order they decide. If the reason you’re comparing these two is that you’d rather read a fixed list of outlets you picked, that’s a different kind of app.

In Hushread you add the outlets you already read in either app, as feeds or websites, and every article arrives newest first with no ads and nothing ranked or injected. It’s on iPhone, iPad, Android and the web, with a free plan, and Pro is $2.08 a month billed yearly. It has no political slider, no magazines and no local tab, so it replaces neither app’s best feature.

For other options, see my Apple News alternatives. If SmartNews is the one you’re leaving, the SmartNews alternatives roundup covers it.

FAQ

Is SmartNews better than Apple News?

For most iPhone users in the US, UK, Canada or Australia, Apple News is the better default: it’s preinstalled, editor-led and its privacy label lists no tracking. SmartNews is better if you use Android, want a political-balance slider, or want to pay to remove most ads.

SmartNews or Apple News on iPhone: which tracks you more?

SmartNews. Its App Store label lists nine data categories that may be used to track you across other companies’ apps and websites, while Apple News lists none, though Apple still links some data to you for its own ads.

Does Apple News+ remove ads?

Apple doesn’t say it does, and readers report it doesn’t. News+ adds more than 500 publications for $12.99 a month; SmartNews is the one of the two that sells an ad-free plan, in the US only.

Is SmartNews safe after the 2026 data breach?

SmartNews said the unauthorized access on October 31 exposed 1,033 internal user IDs and partner email addresses, not passwords or card details, and it had confirmed no misuse. Some US features, including rewards, were still suspended on November 4.

Can I use Apple News on Android?

No. Apple News runs only on Apple devices, and only in Australia, Canada, the UK and the US. SmartNews has an Android app, and my SmartNews vs Google News comparison covers the main Android alternative.

If you’re on an iPhone in one of Apple’s four countries and News+ magazines appeal to you, stay with Apple News. If you need Android, a slider across the political spectrum, or a cheap ad-free option, SmartNews is still a fine choice once its paused features are back. And if what you actually want is your own outlets in order, try Hushread.