Manchester United crisis deepens after Como defeat and Bournemouth loss
Michael Carrick's future remains contested after United followed their Champions League humiliation with another defeat, while his decision to bench Bruno Fernandes intensified scrutiny.
By Hushread Stories, from 24 outlets · First published 26 Oct 2026 · Chapter 6 of 6
Earlier: Manchester United bench Fernandes after Como defeat exposes dispute with Carrick
In brief
- Como beat Manchester United 4 to 1 on October 21, with Nico Paz scoring twice and providing an assist.
- Captain Bruno Fernandes publicly criticised United's tactics, exposing tensions with manager Michael Carrick after the Champions League defeat.
- Carrick accepted responsibility for United's slump but maintained he could reverse it before the Bournemouth match.
- Fernandes started on the bench against Bournemouth on October 25, when United lost 3 to 0 at home.
- Coverage differs on Carrick's status, with one report announcing his dismissal while others describe his future as unresolved.
Timeline · 7 moments
Dismissal headline emerges amid uncertainty over Carrick's future
Telegraph India ↗Bournemouth inflict another heavy defeat at Old Trafford
BBC - Home ↗Fernandes left on bench for Bournemouth home match
L'Équipe ↗Carrick accepts blame but backs himself to recover
Al Jazeera ↗Sources expect Carrick to remain for Bournemouth match
ESPN FC ↗Fernandes publicly questions tactics after Champions League loss
Al Jazeera ↗Nico Paz leads Como to emphatic United defeat
La Repubblica ↗How it started
Como's 4-1 victory over Manchester United on October 21 was built around Nico Paz. He scored twice and supplied the assist for Douvikas, while Ramon also scored, according to La Repubblica. It was Como's second Champions League victory.
The match took place at the Giuseppe Sinigaglia in the third round of the competition's league phase, CNN Brasil reported. For United, the defeat brought an already difficult season into sharper focus. DIE WELT described mounting pressure on manager Michael Carrick amid poor results in both the Champions League and Premier League.
How it unfolded
On October 21, captain Bruno Fernandes publicly questioned United's tactics after the defeat, according to Al Jazeera. ESPN FC reported that Carrick and Fernandes appeared to trade criticism, turning the aftermath into a dispute between manager and captain as well as an examination of the performance.
The criticism itself became contentious. Sky Sports reported that Henry Winter disagreed with Fernandes publicly challenging Carrick's tactics, while ESPN reported Jamie Carragher's condemnation of the captain's comments.
On October 22, sources told ESPN FC that Carrick was expected to remain in charge against Bournemouth. Reports about possible successors were less consistent: La Repubblica said United were exploring Antonio Conte's availability, while Cumhuriyet.com.tr reported claims that Conte had been ruled out and Julian Nagelsmann was the strongest candidate. These were reports about options, not an announced appointment.
On October 23, Carrick accepted blame for the slump but expressed confidence in a turnaround, Al Jazeera reported. He also refused to rule out dropping Fernandes, according to BBC Football. By October 24, the BBC reported that United had gone seven games without a win.
On October 25, Fernandes was left on the bench for Bournemouth's visit, L'Équipe reported. Carrick described the selection as a "pure football" decision, according to GB News. United then lost 3-0 at Old Trafford, leaving Carrick under still greater pressure, the BBC reported.
Where it stands
The supplied October 26 coverage does not give a consistent account of Carrick's employment status. A Telegraph India headline says he has been sacked, while the BBC describes his future as under scrutiny and Marca says his position is in serious danger. His dismissal therefore cannot be treated as settled across these reports.
The debate has also widened beyond the manager. Analysis from the BBC argues that the owners' problems are bigger than Carrick's future, while commentary in Guardian Sport frames the defeat and the Fernandes decision within broader institutional failures. Those are assessments of responsibility, rather than evidence of a confirmed change in leadership.
What to watch
The immediate question is whether United confirm Carrick's departure or retain him. The conflicting October 26 reports make a definitive account of that decision the most important missing development.
Fernandes' position is another unresolved issue. Carrick declined to confirm he would remain captain before the Bournemouth match, according to The42. Being benched establishes a selection decision, but the supplied coverage does not establish that he has lost the captaincy.


