Milburn review urges overhaul of youth welfare, ending sickness benefits for under-25s
Alan Milburn's long-awaited report on young people out of work proposes replacing disability payments with a youth allowance and a job guarantee, splitting opinion inside Labour and across Whitehall.
By Hushread Stories, from 8 outlets · First published 17 Nov 2026 · Chapter 1 of 2
In brief
- Alan Milburn's review says about 440,000 young people need to get into work, calling for a complete system reset.
- Under-25s would lose main sickness and disability benefits, replaced by a youth allowance and access to local funds.
- Milburn wants a legal guarantee of a job or training, plus national insurance cuts to encourage hiring young workers.
- He says the benefits bill will take a decade to fall and that the plan is not pain-free.
- Prime Minister Andy Burnham backs the direction, calling benefits a backstop, while some Labour MPs object and No 10 weighs wider changes.
Timeline · 10 moments
Report criticises Labour policies and urges targeted tax cuts
Yahoo! UK News ↗Report published calling for complete system reset
BBC ↗Review to propose national insurance cut for young workers
BBC ↗Burnham calls benefits the backstop in generational reform
Yahoo! UK News ↗Milburn warns benefits bill will take decade to fall
Guardian Politics ↗Milburn calls for legal guarantee of job or training
BBC ↗No 10 weighs extending overhaul to older age groups
Top Stories ↗Labour revolt reported as cost concerns emerge
Daily Mail ↗Young disabled people lose PIP but can seek local fund
UK news | The Guardian ↗Review previewed: young people to lose sickness benefits
The Times ↗How it started
Alan Milburn, the former health secretary, spent a year working on a government-commissioned review into young people not in education, employment or training, known as Neets. The question was why so many young people were out of work and what the state should do about it.
From 11 November 2026, the findings began to leak out. The Times reported that the review would call for young people to be taken off sickness benefits and for a new youth allowance, as part of what it called the biggest welfare overhaul in over a decade. The BBC said some under-25s could see reductions in what they are entitled to.
How it unfolded
On 12 November, the details sharpened. The Guardian reported that some young disabled people would lose personal independence payments but could apply to a local fund instead, with Milburn wanting to "tear up the old approach". The Daily Mail said a Labour revolt was already brewing and claimed the plan would cost taxpayers £6bn more. The Times reported that No 10 would support the overhaul, though Andy Burnham's spokeswoman declined to say whether existing claimants would be protected.
The next day, the Guardian reported that Downing Street was considering extending the approach beyond the under-25s to older age groups. On 14 November, Milburn told the BBC that young people should have a legal guarantee of a job or training, which he called an "opportunity guarantee".
On 15 November, Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden said, according to the Hereford Times, that some people would not receive benefits they are currently eligible for. Milburn told the Guardian "there is no such thing as a free lunch", warning it would take a decade for the benefits bill to come down, while downplaying opposition within Labour. Burnham promised "generational" reform, saying benefits would be "the backstop, not the starting point", according to Yahoo News. The Times reported the review would propose wage subsidies for Neets and benefit cuts for those who refuse help, and the BBC said it would call for national insurance cuts for under-25s.
The report was published on 16 November. The BBC reported its call for a complete system reset to get 440,000 young people into work. The Times said Milburn warned that one in six young people could be Neets by 2031 without action. The Guardian said he urged Burnham to spend billions on a new deal for the young, and Express & Star reported the aim of cutting the Neet rate from 13% to around 5% by 2036, with a youth allowance replacing the disability benefits.
Where it stands
Coverage on 17 November turned to blame and cost. The Daily Mail and GB News reported that the report criticises Labour's own policies for damaging young people's job prospects. Yahoo News said Milburn urged Burnham to reverse some of Rachel Reeves's tax rise on firms, with targeted national insurance cuts.
On the numbers, The Times cited a prediction of 1.27 million young people out of education, employment or training by 2031. The Guardian reported Milburn saying the plan could cut the welfare bill before the election but that overall savings would take years, with initial costs acknowledged.
Separately, Express & Star reported that the Office for National Statistics put the jobless rate at 4.6% in the three months to September, while vacancies fell further.
What to watch
The main open question is how much of the review the government adopts, and how it pays for it. The costs, including national insurance cuts and wage subsidies, sit against savings that Milburn says will take a decade.
Also unresolved is whether existing claimants would be protected, which Burnham's spokeswoman would not say, and whether the changes extend to older groups, as No 10 was reported to be considering. Labour backbench resistance will decide how far ministers can go.


