Alaska Orders Peltola Campaign Probe as Trump Challenges Senate Certification
A lawsuit over two candidates named Dan Sullivan has expanded into a recruitment controversy and criminal investigation, days before an Alaska election that could affect Senate control.
By Hushread Stories, from 37 outlets · First published 29 Oct 2026 · Chapter 5 of 5
Earlier: Trump Pushes Alaska Ballot Challenge as State Seeks to Dismiss Lawsuit
In brief
- The Justice Department seeks to block Alaska Senate certification if Republican incumbent Dan Sullivan narrowly loses.
- Mary Peltola and other opponents have sought dismissal, while Alaska's Republican led government also challenged the lawsuit.
- Reporting linked Peltola aides and national Democrats to recruiting another Sullivan, allegations her campaign has denied.
- Trump called for Peltola's prosecution, and Alaska's governor ordered a criminal investigation into her campaign.
- The judge has expedited the certification case ahead of the November 3 election, with dismissal still sought.
Timeline · 10 moments
Alaska governor orders criminal investigation into Peltola campaign
The New York Times ↗Trump accuses Democrats and Peltola campaign of perjury
Axios ↗Trump calls for Peltola to be barred from race
Financial Times World ↗Peltola campaign denies involvement with either Sullivan campaign
ABCNews.com ↗Report links Peltola allies to spoiler recruitment effort
NYTimes.com Home Page (U.S.) ↗Alaska government moves to end Trump certification lawsuit
The Washington Post ↗Judge expedites certification case ahead of Election Day
CNBC International ↗Attorney General Todd Blanche defends election lawsuit
NPR News ↗Peltola and Senate Democrats seek dismissal of lawsuit
NBC News ↗Justice Department seeks to block Alaska Senate certification
Global News ↗How it started
The Trump administration went to court before Alaska voters had finished choosing their next senator. The Justice Department seeks to prevent certification if Republican incumbent Sen. Dan Sullivan narrowly loses, arguing that voters could mistakenly choose another candidate with the same name, according to The Conversation.
Alaska's Senate ballot has four candidates, including two named Dan Sullivan, Reason reported. The administration's requested intervention targets a narrow victory by Democratic nominee Mary Peltola, according to Forbes. It is a challenge to a possible result, not a response to a completed count.
How it unfolded
By October 25, attorneys for Peltola and Senate Democrats had asked a federal judge to dismiss the administration's lawsuit, NBC News reported. Attorney General Todd Blanche defended the suit in an interview, according to NPR News.
On October 26, Peltola was seeking an emergency ruling before the midterms, Forbes reported. The other Dan Sullivan, a schoolteacher, called the preemptive challenge "a gross misuse of the Justice Department," according to The New York Times.
On October 27, the judge expedited the case, according to CNBC International. ABCNews.com reported that the judge appeared skeptical of the department's legal strategy. Alaska's Republican-led government also moved to end the lawsuit, The Washington Post reported.
The dispute changed sharply on October 28. The New York Times reported that operatives aligned with Peltola had spent months recruiting candidates to draw votes from the Republican incumbent. CNBC, citing that reporting, said Peltola campaign aides and Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee officials helped recruit the second Sullivan.
Peltola denied the allegations, according to CBS Top Stories. Her campaign, Alaskans for Mary, said it "has no involvement with either Sullivan campaign," ABCNews.com reported. Trump responded by demanding that she be barred from running, according to Financial Times World.
On October 29, Axios reported that Trump had accused Democrats and Peltola's campaign of fraud and perjury. Alaska's governor ordered a criminal investigation into the campaign, according to The New York Times. That report said Trump had offered no explanation of what crime may have been committed.
Where it stands
The certification lawsuit and the recruitment investigation are now separate parts of the same election dispute. The court case has been expedited, with Peltola seeking dismissal before Election Day, according to CNBC International. The governor's investigation follows the reporting on candidate recruitment, Forbes reported.
The reporting raises questions about how the second Sullivan entered the race, but the supplied coverage does not establish a criminal offense or resolve the administration's legal claims. Peltola's denial also remains part of the record. The stakes extend beyond Alaska: CNBC reported that the winner could determine which party holds a Senate majority in the next Congress.
What to watch
The immediate question is whether the judge dismisses the Justice Department's case or allows its bid to restrict certification to proceed before the November 3 election. The expedited schedule makes that the next concrete legal decision to watch, according to CNBC International.
The governor's investigation leaves another question unresolved: what conduct investigators will examine and whether any charges follow. A disputed result could also reach the Senate itself. The Hill reported that senators were preparing for a potential floor fight over accepting Alaska's results.


